March 24, 2008

Does the NAACP Defend Black Male Rapists Instead of Black Female and Child Rape Victims? Why?

Gina McCaughley of What About Our Daughters? AfroSpear blog says that she was working on advocating for the victims in the Dunbar Village rape case, a Black woman and child, but the NAACP ignored her calls for aid, she says, responding to her that the NAACP's mission does not include addressing Black on Black crime.

However, when the prosecution of the alleged rapists began, the NAACP DID begin advocating for the alleged rapists, apparently because defending Black accused in the criminal justice system IS part of the NAACP mission.

These facts, as presented by one side - Gina McCaughley - presents a number of difficult questions as to the wisdom and efficacy of the NAACP. Can the NAACP promote "the advancement" of Black people if they indiscriminately defend those who victimize us, just because those victimizers are Black and are being prosecuted by a white criminal justice system?

Is the NAACP's interest in this case to secure equal justice for the accuseds and, if so, what does equal justice entail and require in this case?

When the NAACP gets involved in a case with Black female and minor victims and Black male accuseds, what does equal justice require that the NAACP do for the Black female and minor victims, if anything?

Doesn't a policy that defends rape accuseds from the "system" but does not defend victims from the perpetrators necessarily mean that the NAACP will help mostly help guilty men but not innocent women and children in a case like this one?

Is defending those accused of the most hideous rapes, who may well be guilty, the most effective way to advocate for equal justice for ALL Blacks to receive equal justice in the criminal justice system?

Let's be clear: Everyone, particularly the accuseds, deserves a defense when they are accused of a crime, because many accuseds are not guilty and many Black accuseds who ARE guilty are punished far more harshly than white accuseds would be under similar circumstances. That's why every defendant has a right to a competent and zealous defense from his defense lawyers.

However, every defendant does not have an automatic right to the limited resources of Black civic action groups like the NAACP. Such groups should be able to explain how defending individuals furthers their PROGRAMMATIC mission. I'd certainly like to understand better how defending THESE particular accuseds furthers the programmatic mission of the NAACP.

I admit that I haven't researched this case, and all I can do is pose the questions that occur to me, hoping that my readers can offer more information.

16 comments:

Anonymous said...

Does the NAACP any longer engage in anything that is either logical or beneficial to black people? I say they should be dismantled along with the congressional black caucus, let's start our own chapters!

SheCodes said...

Good questions. I would also like to know how giving R Kelly, a man who videotaped himself having sex with and urinating on a little black girl who was visibly fourteen, "works toward their mission."

I would like to know how it could be that Genarlow Wilson, who did absolutely nothing honorable in the videotape in which and his friends sexed a unconscious/semi conscious girl, and got group fellatio from a clearly underage girl, would "advance thier mission" to make this budding porn star a "guest of honor" at an NAACP banquet last year, instead of any random young black child who kept his nose clean, got good grades, and respected himself and young black girls.

Anonymous said...

remember my crticism about naacp al sharpton an megan williams an them turning tail an running because they had to share the stage with the new black panther party who were also the security there in case them kkk started blasting like when they kiled those communist workers in the carolinas.damn ,security cant speak with the naacp or revs they banned from program.YES FRANCIS THE ANSWER IS YESSSS.OUTRAGE THAT THEY REPRESENT US .THATS THE PROBLEM ,ARE WE STILL COLORED++DAMN+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++TERRELL ALI BEY

Anonymous said...

IF WE CAN DO AWAY WITH THEM I WITH THAT.TERRELL ALI BEY

Francis Holland said...

Terrell, they only represent us if we say they do, if we let them. The problem is that, as ineffectual and irrelevant as they often are, we don't have a clear replacement for them, as with some of our Congressional representation, it has been argued.

Francis Holland said...

shecodes, I think maybe the NAACP's train has left the tracks . . . a long time ago.

Anonymous said...

OK AN WHO SAYS THAT THEY DO,WHO DO YOU/WE PART COMPANY WITH AN WHEN,THE CHRISTIANS ON SUNDAY MORNING CAUSE ITS THE NAACP/CHURCH WHO FORCED INTEGRATION AN SHUT DOWN THE BLACK PROGRAMS BUILDING SCHOOLS A HOSPITALSFOR BLACKSONLY INTHE 20S 30S40S AN THEN THE NAACP STAGNATION IN 1950.KILLED THE PROGRAMS OF REV AMOS CARNEGIE SR WHO HAD A 10,POINT PROGRAM THAT WAS LIKE THE NOI AN BLACK PANTHERS IN TERMS OF SELF HELP.AS A GROUP WE DO WELL LIKE A FIST AS INDIVIDUAL CHASING THE NEXT MANSCREATION FROM 324A.D WE REINFORCE THE SPELL THAT HAS BEN SET UPON US.NAACP IS THE CHURCH THE REV USED TO GO DOOR TO DOOR IN SOUTH JAMAICA FOR DONATION TO JOIN.----------------------------------TERRELL

Anonymous said...

ONLY NON ROMANIZED CHRISTIAN BLACKS DARE DENOUNCE THE NAACP OUT LOUD THE ZEBRA COALITION.AHHH A CLEAR REPLACEMENT WHY NOT OURSELVES WE ARE NOT DOING TO WELL FOLLOWING THIS ONE OR THAT ONE.ITS EASIER TO DO BUT WE DO OK ONN HERE.A GUY ASKED ME WHAT DO YOU BELIEVE IN ,EVERYBODY HASTO BELIEVE IN SOMETHING.THIS IS THE LIMIT LEVELER TO WHAT WE KNOW AN DONT KNOW.ITS THE CONTROLLING FACTOR WE KNOW THEY BELIEVE .THATS HOW TO STAY IN CHARGE IN SILENCE WITH OUT VIOLENCE AND IS A SMALL PART OF THE PROTOCOLS OF THE LEARNED ELDERS OF ZION.JUST READING TECHNIQUES OF THE PROTOCOLS YOU CAN FEEL THEM BEING PRACICED ON YOU WE JUST DONT KNOW SOMEONE IS PRACTICING THEIR WHITE MAGIC.WHY DO BLACK PEOPLE HAVE TO HAVE SOMETHING TO BELIVE INTO MAKE THEM BELIEVE IN THEY SELVES.WHY NOT JUST BE YOU SEE THE EXAMPLE THEY FOLLOW ,THEY WANNA BE US WHILE THEY HATE US.THEY HATE THE ORIGINAL CREATION CAUSE ITS NO THEM .ITS LIKE THE PYRAMIDS NO MATTER WHAT THEY DO THEY CANT DUPLICATE THE ORIGINAL.THAT IM PROUD TO SAY IS US JUST US JUSTICE JESUS/YOSHUA THE SUN OF GOD,MA NOT GAD++SHUKRAN FOR MY MOTHER.+++++++TERRELL

Anonymous said...

AN WHEN THE CHRISTIAN MINISTAR BREAKS COVENANT AN SPEAKS THE TRUTH OUTSIDE OF THE BIBLE ABOUT THE DEVIL HE IS SHUT DOWN.i commemd obamas ministar bout time some one blew the govt up on a sunday morn.TERRELL

Anonymous said...

THEN THE FEMALE[V]DOGS WENT FOR TWO CRUCIFIXIONS,A REAL RITUAL BUT THE OLDER MAN WAS THE SACRIFICE THEY REALLY WANTED.PUT YOUR BLACK SIDE IN CHECK THEY TOLD OBAMA.HE COUNTERED BY USUNG HIS WHITE SIDE TO ESCAPE THE WRECK.GREAT ORATOR.HE CAN ESCAPE THE BLACK SIDE BY SAYING THE RACISM HE GOT FROM HISW WHITE SIDE SOTHEY HAD TO SHUT UP AN BACK OFF HIM.THE OTHER CHAP WASNT SO LUCKY ,OBAMA DIDNT CARRY THE CROSS BUT THE MEDIA ASSASINATED HIM-TERRELLL

Anonymous said...

BLOG IS JUMPIN ----------TERRELL

Anonymous said...

A replacement for the NAACP shouldn't be hard to establish. Afrospear and color of change have been more effective then the NAAACP has been in decades. I've found some of NAACP causes based around taking up for buffoonery as opposed to the reality of black America's dilemmas. They aren't any longer the NAACP of my Grandmother's generation. The organization remains more caught up in who feeds their wallets.

Anonymous said...

THIS IS THE ULTIMATE SPARK PLUG,FREE THINKING UNBOUND,ALLOWS US TO CONNECT WITH THE ANCESTORS THAT ARE AWAKINING US.AN THE LESS WE WAIT TO LISTEN WE GAIN BACK OUR TRUE KNOWLEDGEOF SELF.I DO NOT WORSHIP THE DEVIL,BUT I STUDY HIS ASS LIKE I DO.STUDY THE DEVIL AN YOU HAVE NO CHOICE TO FIND GOD.SHE IS HIDDEN JUST LIKE ME IN MY MOTHERS WOMB FOR 9 MONTHS.QUEEN AFUA ,MYRA EL,QUEEN VALAHRA RENITA EL HARRE BEY,SISTER SHILOH,DR JEWEL POOKRAM,SUZAR, SISTER RADINE AMEN RA,SISTER NIDERAH ZENABU,SISTER PUMA LA GITANA,SISTER DEBORAH MAAT MOORE,DR CHARSHEE MACINTYRE,PATRICIA NEWTON,DR MARIMBA ANI,DR ADELAIDE SANFORD,ALL EARTHS OF THE GODS ,SISTER ZUL ZAHARITU, SHIEKESS NIKA AND SISTER RASMARIAH BEY FROM THE MOORISHS SCIENCE TEMPLE OF AMERICA, ASBURY PARK N.J.,.SISTER YAFFA BEY,EMPRESS VERDIACEE T GOSTON CHIEFTESS OF THE WASHITAW NATION,EL EMPRESS KEISHA DEVINE,ASAATA SHAKUR IN EXILE IN CUBA.I HAVE LEARNED FROM ALL OF THESE WOMAN PLUS THE ONES IN MY FAMILY OF COURSE FIRST AN FOREMOST.I NEED NOT MENTION MEN OR THE MEN CAUSE THIS IS FOR THE SISTERS WHO ARE TIRED OF HEARING SOME/SUM OF US MEN TELL THEM WHO THEY ARE AN WHERE THEY CAME FROM.BLACK MAN STILL TELLING YOU THAT YOU COME FROM HIS RIB? NAACP AN SINISTER MINISTERS STILL KICKING THAT WEAK *&#!.THESE LADIES HAVE GOT THEIR POWER BACK NOT FEMINIST POWER BUT THEIR BLACK POWER THIS IS IT FEMINIST POWER COMES FROM THE SISTERS NATURALLY THEY SHOULLDNT HAVE TO RALLY FOR IT FROM THEIR SUNS THE MEN FOR I THE SUN AM A LIVUNG EXAMPLE OF FEMININE POWER.EVERYTIME THEIR IS A BIRTH THATS FEMININE POWER, GOD POWER ,CREATOR POWER.IT MUST BE HIDDEN CAUSE ITS RIGHT IN OUR GRILL ALL THE TIME.AGAIN THATS WHY THEY WANTED TO BURN THE BRA LIKE A FLAG AN BAN IT,SOME WOMAN WONT WEAR IT YOU WONT DIE WITHOUT IT.IT WAS MADE TO LOOK LIKE US NATURALLY WITH THE STANDING OUT AN UP .DESIGNED AHTER THE SHAPE OF TGHE BODY OF HOTTENTOT VENUS THE CORSAGE WITH THE WIRE FAKE BATT STICKING OUT TO AN THE DRESS WOULD ALSO HAVE A PUSH UP SO THE CHEST WAS FEATURED .THIS WAS FOR EUROPEAN LADIES.THATS WHY IT LOOKS LIKE THE SCALES OF JUSTICE[MAAT] TURNED UP AN STRAPPED OR HELD.THEN THEY MADE THEIR GODESS[SEARCH IF YOU DONT BELIEVE TO KNOW} {COLUMBIA/LIBERTY /JUSTICE TO REPLACE MAAT. JUST LIKE LIPSTICK AN PERFUME BASED IN ALCOHOL THE BIGGEST POISON ON EARTH FOR THE WOMB.WE DO NOT NEED THE NAACP TO HELP US INTEGRATE ANY MORE WE ALREADY INTEGRATED ENOUGH BARACK OBAMA IS LIVING PROOF.DINOSAURS ARE EXTINCT.1913-2008.95 YEARS AN THEY CANT BACK A BACK WOODS RAPE VICTIM .AFTER THERE COUP IN 1950 ECONIMICALLY WE HAVE SUNK FROM OWNERSHIP TO SERVITUDE JOBS,IN COMMERCE WITH ALL OTHER CULTURES FEEDING OFF OUR LABOR DOLLAR FOR THEIR ADVANCE MENT JUST LIKE AKA LYNN SAYS.WE USED TO OWN OR HAVE LAND ,A DOCTOR AN A LAWYER IS GOOD BUT THEY TOOK OUR LAND GAVEUS PROJECTS UNEMPLOYMENT AN FACTORY WORK WHICH DID NOT WORK THEN 1950S ,HEROIN IN THE GODFATHER FOR THE NIGGERS AN SPICS THATS WHAT THEY SAID IN THE MOVIE SO EXCUSE THE USE BUT IS NOT ABUSE BY ME ITS THEM WHO WILL BE THE FIRST ONE TO BLAME WHO THEY ROSE ON.DOPE SALES GOT ITALIANS/ASHKANAHS JEWS OUT OF THE SOUTH BRONX PROJECTS INTO BELMONT HOMES 50S 60S .OUR DOLLARS FINANCED THIS.FEW OF US GOT RICH TOO AN THY MAKE MOVIES WITH DDENZEL BOUT THAT.REAL HEROS MAKES YOU SUN WANNA GROW UP AN BE JUST LIKE HIM.AT LEAST THAT WAS TRUE UNLIKE NEW JACK CITY WHO COULD HAVE BEEN ANY DRUG CREW OPERATIN IN NY AT THAT TIME.WE SAW THE BREAK FROM THE ITALIAN MIDDLEMEN IN THE DRUG INDUSTRY+++ THE CIA OLLIE NORTH WITH COCAINE CRACK.THAT THE US MILITARY BRINGS IN.WHO BRINGS ALL THE POPPY OUT OF AFGHANISTAN THE ARMY THATS WHY THEY ARE THERE TO CONTRLLIN THE FLOW OF THE POPPY SEED FOR MORPHINE, OPIUM AN HEROIN TRADE+TELL ME THATS NOT LIKE OIL AN GOLD AN SUGAR+++++++NAACP HAS DESTROYED THE COLOR IN THE PEOPLE AN ADVANCED THEM BACK TO THE BACK++BY CREATING THE LACK FOR THE NEXT MAN TO ATTACK THE BLACK.+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++THIS IS THE BROTHER BLACK AN THIS IS THE BLACK ATTACK RIGHT THE *&#$ ABOUT NOW++++++++I.S.L.A.M++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++PEACE++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++TERRELL ALI BEY

Anonymous said...

WHY IS IT THAT THESE GROUPS WHO WE JOIN FOR STRENGTH/SUPPORT. MAKE US WEAKER AS INDIVIDUALS.AN WHEN WE INDIVIDUALLY LEARN AN STUDY TOGETHER LIKE THIS WE ARE STRONGER AS A GROUP WITH NO ONE GROUP LEADING US DOWN OR BACK TO OLE VIRGINNY.IF WE BLACK I CAN WORK THAT IN THERE LIKE DR.ALI MUHAMMED TO BRING US BACK BUT EVEN HE NOR SAA NETER WILL CONCEDE TO NEGRO OR NAACP COLORED PEOPLE ,WE DONT TURN COLORS WE ARE THE COLOR ISNT ED PAST-TENSE IN ETYMOLOGY SO THE COLORED CAME FROM US ITS A SPELL,SPELLED WRONG WITH THE ED AT THE END OF COLOR,ALL CAME FROM US SO ITS US WHO HAVE BEEN FALSELY BRANDED COLORED BY THE DAMN COLORED THEMSELF,WITH YOUR OUR INTELLIGENCE BACK WE NEED NOT OTHER TO INFORM US.COLLECTIVELY THE MOORS WHO SAY THEY BLACK AN THE MOORS WHO SAY THEY NOT BLACK WILL NOT ACCEPT HIS WHIGGAMORE PROPOGATED CHATTEL PROPERTY DEFACTO TERM APPLIED A BRANDED UPON US.THE NAACP KEEPS US DEAD IN THE EYES OF THE LAW AN KNOW DAMN WELL CAUSE IT WAS STARTED BY ASKANASH/ALBIONS/ WHIGGAMORES/ROMANS/GAULS/ DIXIE DEMOS ECT WHO KNOW WHAT THAT MEANS IN LAW (MAN-KIND)BE-ING(HUMAN) THEY THEM SELVES STOLE THE WHITE STATUS WE AGREE TO LET THEM HAVE BECAUSE OF THEIR PALE RUDDY RED SKIN IN 1863.THE DATES OF BOOKS SHOW NEGRO WASNT WRITTEN IN BOOKS USED TILL 17O5 AS A TERM FOR A HUMAN BEING A MOOR OR AS THEY PUT IT BLACK A MOOR .THE WHITE MOORS THEN WOULD BE THE 22EUROPEAN SONS WHO STARTED THIS UNITED STATESAAN TURNED IT TO UNION STATES ,THEN BOUND AN ENSLAVED US ON OUR OWN LAND.37 MOORS GOES IN FRONT OF 22 CAUSE IT WAS OUR LAND.THIS LAND IS YOUR LAND THIS LAND IS MY LAND ,THESONG EVEN SAYS SUBLIMINALLY THIS WAS YOURS AN I TOOK IT FROM YOU THEN MAD A BOBBY MCFERRIN DONT WORRY BE HAPPY SONG ABOUT IT.THANK YOU MY PEOPLE BECAUSE YOU ARE THE SPARK THATS ACTIVATES THIS TYPE OF OR LEVEL OF KNOWLEDGE OUT OF ME.THIS IS NOT REHURSED.THIS COMES STRAIGHT TO MY HEAD AFTER QUESTION FROM THE BLOG HOST.IF HE AN YOU GENARATE ALL THIS ENERGY FROM ME IMAGINE IF EVERYONE OF YOU FELT LIKE US WITH THE URGE AN ADDICTION TO TEACH UPON DEMAND UPON CALL THEN NO ONE WOULD BE ABLE TO MISLEAD MISREAD MISCREED ALL ON THE SAME PAGE.+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++TERRELL

Anonymous said...

WHY IS IT THAT THESE GROUPS WHO WE JOIN FOR STRENGTH/SUPPORT. MAKE US WEAKER AS INDIVIDUALS.AN WHEN WE INDIVIDUALLY LEARN AN STUDY TOGETHER LIKE THIS WE ARE STRONGER AS A GROUP WITH NO ONE GROUP LEADING US DOWN OR BACK TO OLE VIRGINNY.IF WE BLACK I CAN WORK THAT IN THERE LIKE DR.ALI MUHAMMED TO BRING US BACK BUT EVEN HE NOR SAA NETER WILL CONCEDE TO NEGRO OR NAACP COLORED PEOPLE ,WE DONT TURN COLORS WE ARE THE COLOR ISNT ED PAST-TENSE IN ETYMOLOGY SO THE COLORED CAME FROM US ITS A SPELL,SPELLED WRONG WITH THE ED AT THE END OF COLOR,ALL CAME FROM US SO ITS US WHO HAVE BEEN FALSELY BRANDED COLORED BY THE DAMN COLORED THEMSELF,WITH YOUR OUR INTELLIGENCE BACK WE NEED NOT OTHER TO INFORM US.COLLECTIVELY THE MOORS WHO SAY THEY BLACK AN THE MOORS WHO SAY THEY NOT BLACK WILL NOT ACCEPT HIS WHIGGAMORE PROPOGATED CHATTEL PROPERTY DEFACTO TERM APPLIED A BRANDED UPON US.THE NAACP KEEPS US DEAD IN THE EYES OF THE LAW AN KNOW DAMN WELL CAUSE IT WAS STARTED BY ASKANASH/ALBIONS/ WHIGGAMORES/ROMANS/GAULS/ DIXIE DEMOS ECT WHO KNOW WHAT THAT MEANS IN LAW (MAN-KIND)BE-ING(HUMAN) THEY THEM SELVES STOLE THE WHITE STATUS WE AGREE TO LET THEM HAVE BECAUSE OF THEIR PALE RUDDY RED SKIN IN 1863.THE DATES OF BOOKS SHOW NEGRO WASNT WRITTEN IN BOOKS USED TILL 17O5 AS A TERM FOR A HUMAN BEING A MOOR OR AS THEY PUT IT BLACK A MOOR .THE WHITE MOORS THEN WOULD BE THE 22EUROPEAN SONS WHO STARTED THIS UNITED STATESAAN TURNED IT TO UNION STATES ,THEN BOUND AN ENSLAVED US ON OUR OWN LAND.37 MOORS GOES IN FRONT OF 22 CAUSE IT WAS OUR LAND.THIS LAND IS YOUR LAND THIS LAND IS MY LAND ,THESONG EVEN SAYS SUBLIMINALLY THIS WAS YOURS AN I TOOK IT FROM YOU THEN MAD A BOBBY MCFERRIN DONT WORRY BE HAPPY SONG ABOUT IT.THANK YOU MY PEOPLE BECAUSE YOU ARE THE SPARK THATS ACTIVATES THIS TYPE OF OR LEVEL OF KNOWLEDGE OUT OF ME.THIS IS NOT REHURSED.THIS COMES STRAIGHT TO MY HEAD AFTER QUESTION FROM THE BLOG HOST.IF HE AN YOU GENARATE ALL THIS ENERGY FROM ME IMAGINE IF EVERYONE OF YOU FELT LIKE US WITH THE URGE AN ADDICTION TO TEACH UPON DEMAND UPON CALL THEN NO ONE WOULD BE ABLE TO MISLEAD MISREAD MISCREED ALL ON THE SAME PAGE.+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++TERRELL

Anonymous said...

terrell ali bey